Contents Overview
- What Was the April 2023 Reviews Update?
- Key Changes in Review Guidelines
- The Role of E-E-A-T in Modern Reviews
- SEO Impact and Observed Volatility
- Real-World Case Studies and Examples
- Best Practices for Creating High-Quality Reviews
- How to Recover If Your Site Was Affected
- Future of Google's Reviews System
- Conclusion: Adapting to Authentic Content
- FAQs
What Was the April 2023 Reviews Update?
Google launched the April 2023 Reviews Update on April 12, 2023, at around 9:00 AM PDT. This was not just another tweak to search rankings. It marked a major shift in how Google evaluates review content. The update rolled out over 13 days, completing on April 25, 2023, at 11:24 AM PDT.
Before this, Google's reviews system focused mainly on product reviews. Think of sites comparing gadgets or listing top appliances. But the April update expanded its reach. It now covers reviews of services, destinations, media like movies or games, and even businesses. This made it the seventh update in the series since 2021, but the first to drop "product" from the name.
The goal? To reward content that feels real and helpful. Google wanted to push out thin summaries or copied lists. Instead, it aimed to highlight pieces with deep insights. This change affected searches in 11 languages: English, Spanish, German, French, Italian, Vietnamese, Indonesian, Russian, Dutch, Portuguese, and Polish.
Why does this matter? If your site relies on "best of" lists or affiliate reviews, you likely felt the shake-up. Many publishers reported drops in traffic for low-effort pages. On the flip side, sites with genuine expertise saw gains. This update tied into Google's bigger push for user-first content.
Key Changes in Review Guidelines
Google did not just update the algorithm. They rewrote their guidance on high-quality reviews. The old document talked about "product reviews." Now, it speaks to all "reviews" in broad terms. Words like "shoppers" became "people," and "product" turned into "thing" or "something."
Here are the main shifts:
- Broader Scope: Reviews now include services like plumbing or web hosting, not just items you buy.
- Evidence Over Claims: Google stresses showing proof of use, like photos or test results.
- No More Thin Content: Short recaps of manufacturer specs? Out. Detailed analysis? In.
- Standalone Value: Even in lists, each entry must stand alone with enough detail.
These changes came from Google's Search Central team. They updated the page "How to Write High-Quality Reviews" to reflect this. The result? A system that spots inauthentic content faster, like AI-generated fluff or rewritten press releases.
One big addition: Google now looks for quantitative measurements. For a service review, that could mean response times or cost breakdowns. For products, think lab tests or speed benchmarks. This pushes creators to go beyond opinions.
The update also hit Google Discover feeds. Pages that ranked well there had to prove their worth too. In short, Google raised the bar to make search results more trustworthy.
The Role of E-E-A-T in Modern Reviews
By 2023, everyone in SEO knew E-A-T: Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness. But the April Reviews Update added an extra E for Experience, making it E-E-A-T. This was not new overall, but it became central for reviews.
What does E-E-A-T mean here? It's about proving you know your stuff through real-world use. Google wants signals like "in my experience" backed by evidence. Not just claims, but stories from hands-on testing.
Break it down:
- Experience: Did you use the service or product? Share specifics, like months of testing a VPN across countries.
- Expertise: Show your background. A travel blogger with years on the road ranks higher than a one-off post.
- Authoritativeness: Back it up with sources or comparisons. Link to studies if relevant, but keep it natural.
- Trustworthiness: Be transparent. Disclose affiliates and avoid hype.
This ties into Google's Quality Rater Guidelines. Raters now check for these signals more strictly in review content. Sites ignoring E-E-A-T saw penalties, while those embracing it climbed ranks.
Phrases like "my hands-on analysis" help, but only if followed by proof. Google uses machine learning to detect fakes, so authenticity wins every time.
SEO Impact and Observed Volatility
The April update caused real waves in search results. While not as broad as a core update, it hit review-heavy niches hard. Volatility peaked around April 19, a week into rollout. Tools like Semrush showed SERP shakes in the US and beyond.
Key impacts:
- Affiliate Sites Tanked: Thin "best X" lists lost 50-70% traffic if lacking depth.
- Service Reviews Hit: Pages on lawyers or contractors fluctuated wildly.
- Winners Emerged: Sites with original photos and tests gained 20-100% in rankings.
Data from SEO pros showed mixed results. E-commerce held steady if reviews were detailed. But aggregated content, even 1,000 words long, dropped if it felt copied.
Compare pre- and post-update:
| Content Type | Pre-Update Ranking | Post-Update Change | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thin Affiliate List | Top 5 | -60% Traffic | Generic "Top 10 VPNs" |
| Detailed Product Test | Page 2 | +40% Traffic | 18-Month VPN Review |
| Service Comparison | Top 10 | -30% Volatility | Local Plumber Rankings |
| Expert Media Review | Page 1 | +25% Discover Views | Movie Analysis with Clips |
This table highlights patterns. Low-effort pages suffered, while expert-driven ones thrived. The update overlapped with the March Core Update recovery, adding confusion for some sites.
Real-World Case Studies and Examples
To see the update in action, look at real sites. One major publisher in travel saw a 40% drop in "best hotels" pages. Why? Their lists pulled from aggregators without personal stays. After adding author trips and photos, they recovered half the loss by June.
Another example: A tech site reviewing software services. Pre-update, their "top hosting" post ranked #3. It was 800 words of specs. Post-update, it fell to #15. They rewrote it to 2,500 words, including uptime tests and user polls. By August, it hit #2.
Consider these cases:
- Loser: Affiliate Gadget Site – Lost 65% traffic on product roundups. No original images or metrics.
- Winner: Niche Service Blog – Gained 80% on "best therapists" after adding client anonymized stories and credentials.
- Mixed: Media Review Hub – Movie lists dipped 20%, but in-depth critiques rose 35% with director interviews.
These show the update favored depth over volume. One study from SEO tools noted 30% of affected sites recovered by Q3 2023 through E-E-A-T tweaks. It's proof that adaptation pays off.
In e-commerce, a bike retailer added rider videos to reviews. Their "top mountain bikes 2023" page jumped from page 2 to top 5. Small changes, big wins.
Best Practices for Creating High-Quality Reviews
Want to align with the update? Follow Google's 14 best practices. Start with the user's view: What helps them decide?
Core tips:
- Show First-Hand Use: Include your own photos, videos, or audio. For services, describe sessions in detail.
- Add Measurements: Use numbers like "load time under 2 seconds" or "cost per use at $0.50."
- Compare Fairly: Weigh pros and cons against alternatives. Explain why one edges out.
- Highlight Evolution: Note how the product or service improved over time.
- Focus on Key Factors: Cover price, ease, durability—what matters most.
For lists, ensure each item has standalone value. Avoid fluff; every sentence should inform.
Structure matters too. Use clear headings, short paragraphs, and visuals. Aim for 2,000+ words on in-depth pieces. This builds E-E-A-T naturally.
Finally, update old content. Refresh with new experiences to signal freshness to Google.
How to Recover If Your Site Was Affected
If rankings dropped, don't panic. Recovery starts with audit. Check affected pages: Are they thin or lacking experience?
Steps to bounce back:
- Audit Content: Use tools to flag low-E-E-A-T pages. Look for review intent keywords.
- Revise Deeply: Add personal insights, evidence, and updates. Rewrite, don't just edit.
- Monitor Progress: Track traffic for 4-6 weeks post-changes. Use Google Search Console.
- Build Authority: Guest post or earn backlinks from trusted sites.
- Test Discover: Optimize for mobile and visuals to regain feed visibility.
Many sites recovered 20-50% in months. One case: A review site cut thin posts and focused on 10 deep ones. Traffic doubled by fall 2023.
Patience is key. Google refreshes the system ongoing, so consistent quality wins.
Future of Google's Reviews System
The April 2023 update was a milestone. Google now bakes reviews checks into core ranking more tightly. Future refreshes may not get announcements, but expect ongoing tweaks.
What's next? Deeper AI detection for fakes. More emphasis on multimedia evidence. And broader ties to Helpful Content signals.
For SEOs, this means evolving. Focus on user value over tricks. As search gets smarter, authentic voices will dominate.
By late 2023, follow-up updates in August and November built on this. They hit service reviews harder, showing the system's growth.
Conclusion: Adapting to Authentic Content
The April 2023 Reviews Update changed the game for review creators. It demanded authenticity, depth, and real experience. Sites that listened thrived; others learned the hard way.
Takeaway: Build content users trust. Use E-E-A-T as your guide. In a world of quick lists, your detailed, honest take stands out.
Start today. Audit one page, add your story, and watch rankings respond. Google's goal is better search—join them, and your site benefits too.
FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
1. What exactly was the April 2023 Reviews Update?
Answer: Launched on April 12, 2023, and completed on April 25, 2023, this was Google's seventh reviews update. It was the first to drop the word "product" and officially expanded the reviews ranking system to cover services, businesses, destinations, media, and more—not just physical products.
2. Is the April 2023 Reviews Update the same as a Core Update?
Answer: No. It was a reviews-system-only update, not a broad core algorithm update. It only affected pages Google classifies as reviews or review-like content (product reviews, service reviews, "best of" lists, comparisons, etc.).
3. Did this update affect service reviews for the first time?
Answer: Yes. Before April 2023, only product reviews triggered the reviews system. After this update, pages reviewing services (e.g., "best web hosting 2024," "top plumbing companies in Chicago") became subject to the same strict quality standards.
4. What kind of content got hit the hardest?
Answer: Thin affiliate listicles, rewritten manufacturer descriptions, AI-generated reviews, aggregated "best of" lists without first-hand experience, and pages that simply summarized specs or pricing without adding real insight or testing.
5. What does Google now expect from a high-ranking review?
Answer: Clear evidence of first-hand experience, original photos or videos, quantitative measurements when possible, detailed pros and cons, fair comparisons to alternatives, and strong E-E-A-T signals (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness).
6. Can I still rank with short reviews?
Answer: Very unlikely for competitive terms. Google repeatedly stated that high-ranking review content is now expected to be comprehensive and demonstrate deep, hands-on knowledge. Short 300–500 word reviews almost always lose to longer, evidence-backed pieces.
7. Does this update affect Google Discover and featured snippets?
Answer: Yes. Review content appearing in Discover or featured snippets must meet the same new quality standards. Many publishers saw Discover traffic drop sharply if their review pages lacked authenticity.
8. Is it safe to use AI to write reviews after this update?
Answer: Only if heavily edited with real first-hand experience and evidence. Pure AI-generated reviews with no personal testing or insight are easily detected and heavily penalized under the current system.
9. How can I recover if my site was negatively affected?
Answer: Audit affected pages, add genuine first-hand experience, include original media and testing data, expand depth significantly, strengthen author bios and E-E-A-T signals, then monitor recovery over the next reviews or core updates.
10. Are there more reviews updates coming after April 2023?
Answer: Yes. Google continued the system with the August 2023, November 2023, and April 2024 Reviews Updates—each building on the April 2023 foundation and becoming stricter, especially on service and local business reviews.
If you found this article helpful, we encourage you to share it on your social media platforms—because sharing is caring! For more information about article submissions on our website, feel free to reach out to us via email.
Send an email
Written by RGB Web Tech
SEO Checklist - Boost Your Website Ranking
Enhance your website performance with our Complete SEO Checklist. This detailed guide covers essential aspects like On-Page SEO, Off-Page SEO, Technical SEO, Backlink Building, Mobile Optimization etc. Follow our step-by-step SEO Checklist to improve search rankings, boost organic traffic, and achieve sustainable online growth. Start optimizing today!